i-chingS

How Did Writing Evolve?

28 February 2020
James Newton at
English Language Evenings III Moscow

QR code

http://russkiy.fun/ele/writing/

children's names
reading to children
a mug drawn with the names of drinks
Russian alphabet
Arabic letter
Thai alphabet
domestic animals
Evolutionary diagram
Biomass
human migration
Sumerian clay block
Shang dynasty oracle bone
Dresden Codex
From pictogram to abstract shape
boustrophedon story
Scott McCloud: Understanding Comics
plough
snakes and ladders
brain activity
Neural Signatures of Reading and Writing

exaptation

noun: countable and uncountable, plural exaptations

The use of a biological structure or function for a purpose other than that for which it initially evolved.

Birds initially developed wings and feathers as a means of heat regulation. The use of wings for flight is an example of exaptation.

Etymology

Blend of ex- +‎ adaptation. Coined in 1982 by palaeontologists Stephen Jay Gould and Elisabeth Vrba to avoid the perceived teleological baggage of the existing term preadaptation.

evolution of feathers

☐ How writing works

☐ What came before writing

☐ Why writing developed

☐ How civilisation started

☐ How writing developed

writing systems
t
Map of Cherokee land
Cherokee land
Sequoyah
Sequoyah, inventor of the Cherokee syllabary [more]

Cree Syllabics: an abugida

aeio
-
p
t
k
ch
m
n
s
y
Source
Singular Dual incl. Dual excl. Plural incl. Plural excl.
1st ᎨᎦ
gega
I'm going
ᎢᏁᎦ
inega
We're going (you + I)
ᎣᏍᏕᎦ
osdega
We two are going (not you)
ᎢᏕᎦ
idega
We're all going (3+, including you)
ᎣᏤᎦ
otsega
We're all going (3+, not you)
2nd ᎮᎦ
hega
You're going
ᏍᏕᎦ
sdega
You two are going
ᎢᏤᎦ
itsega
You're all going
3rd ᎡᎦ
ega
She/he/it's going
ᎠᏁᎦ
anega
They are going
ktb
Example of an abjad (أبجد)
t
Inca empire quipu
braille
The braille system
E.O. Wilson studying ants
E. O. Wilson: ants leave pheromone messages

☑ How writing works

☐ What came before writing

☐ Why writing developed

☐ How civilisation started

☐ How writing developed

animals in lascaux cave
red disks in el castillo
Women's hands
enigatic marks on a cave wall
Geneviève von Petzinger
Genevieve von Petzinger
32 common cave signs
1I
Majiayao jar (ca. 3300–2050 B.C.)
Papua New Guinea Gulf Province mask festival
Ice Age Coastline

☑ How writing works

☑ What came before writing

☐ Why writing developed

☐ How civilisation started

☐ How writing developed

Susa
 
Tokens from Susa
5,000 year old tokens from Susa in Iran
denise schmandt-besserat
Denise Schmandt-Besserat
beer delivery
Accounting: the delivery of beer
Proto-cuneiform tablet
Proto-cuneiform tablet
clay bulla
Bulla enclosing tokens
Fertile crescent
Fertile Cresent 7,500 BCE
Jarmo 1954
Excavations in Jarmo 1954
token meanings
The shape of tokens corresponds to written symbols
Rameses Rebus
Ra (sun god) - mes (child) - su (sedge)
shekel
Shekel
barley field
grains of barley
Barley

☑ How writing works

☑ What came before writing

☑ Why writing developed

☐ How civilisation started

☐ How writing developed

Agriculture changes human interactions

  • Nomadic → sedentary
  • Food storage
  • Specialization + stratification
  • Interdependence
  • Trade
  • Trust
  • Accounting + accountability
  • Law
Jared Diamond
Jared Diamond: Guns, Germs and Steel
Yali
Yali, Papua New Guinea
papua highlands
The highlands in Papua New Guinea
factors of civilisation
fertile crescent
Plants and animals of the fertile crescent
Some animals are not suitable for domestication
Most animals are not suitable for domestication

Factors that determine domestication

  • Diet
  • Growth rate
  • Captive breeding
  • Nasty disposition
  • Tendency to panic
  • Hierarchical social structure
alt text

☑ How writing works

☑ What came before writing

☑ Why writing developed

☑ How civilisation started

☐ How writing developed

timeline of human progress
the art of tracking
Louis Liebenberg
Louis Liebenberg: The Art of Tracking
San trackers
San trackers
san rock art
San rock art
Cybertracker
Cybertracker

Types of tracking

  • Simple
  • Systematic
  • Speculative
San reading tracks
San reading the earth
mule deer doe hoof
Deer hoof
El Castillo
Symbols in El Castillo, Spain
hoof painting
Hoof print cave painting
san people eating
alt text

Exaptation: tracking is not reading

  • Tracks are not arranged neatly, like text
  • Tracks contain no information about sound
  • The tracker imagines movement and intention
  • A tracker sees tracks automatically but understanding needs effort
dyslexia text

Suggestions...